Critique groups are like finding the right pair of jeans - look for that perfect fit. I’ve been involved with several groups and some fit just right and others are too long, too short or my ass would never fit into them.
The 1st one I belonged to had all newbe writers. This would have been great, except I didn’t feel like I was adding value. My feedback (and not just some of it) was falling on deaf ears. I also got feedback (this is great with a few grammer marks). Nothing deep and meaningful, which could have pushed my writing to get better.
The 2nd one I had joined, had a great mix of different writing experience. But one of the critique team members wanted to change all of our voices. Definately, not fun. And then it fell apart because no one could make the meetings or do the critiques. I think we just didn’t quite fit together.
Then I joined the Butterscotch Martini Girls. It’s a great mix of writer experiences and personalities. I enjoy going to the meetings, I feel heard, and I love the feedback from the others.
Don’t hesitate to change if a group isn’t working for you. Sometimes, everyone clicks right off the bat and it’s great. Others, just don’t fit like a glove.
Recently, I was able to attend another critique group meeting. They asked for some help with some compuper stuff. But I was also able to see the dynamics of how they work together. If I could offer some advice for critique groups, here it is:
* Establish how communication would be handled. Do you wait until you meet to give feedback? Can it be sent online? I’ve found that getting the feedback as soon as possible allows the person to think about the information. In their own time, they can take what they want and leave the rest. Sometimes going through each of the critiques in person can be overwelming for some people. Also, evaluate how communication is going and change them as the team grows in experience.
* How often will you meet and where? Make sure you pick something that is conducive for all involved? My current group meets every Tuesday when there isn’t a chapter meeting. We even meet when there is nothing to do in person. This helps us keep our bond and we always know this time has been set aside if we have last minute brainstorming to do or talk about market news, or go over previous feedback we didn’t understand, etc.
* Talk about what you want from a critique. Maybe you write too fast (I wish) and you need people to look out for missing action or dialog. Maybe you need someone to check for the right emotional reaction? They can always check for area’s they are good at, but make sure it’s also helpful to you.
This is just of some of the communication you need to have with your writing/critique partners. I guess what I want from this blog, is for you to never fear making sure you get the most from a critique group. It’s ok to set boundaries, set goals and to change if it’s not being met.
Don’t miss the BSMG’s speaking at the Chocolate Affaire and Romantic Times Booklovers Convention on this topic. Isabella
Share This