Contest feedback - do I cry or laugh?
One thing I’ve learned through the school of hard knocks is that everyone has an opinion and that it’s all subjective. I was looking over some contest feedback I received and wondered does it help? Do writers crave everyone’s opinion or do writers put up with it as the consequence of submitting to a contest?
The judges want to be helpful, they excitedly give you scores, with a flurry of their pens they make comments on your manuscript and try with all their heart to make you a better writer. I wonder if I am.
Do comments like ‘she has very little personality’, or ‘the story itself is intriguing’, or a 1 score on the question - ‘Are the relationship and conflict components of the story properly balanced’, help me become a better writer? I really don’t know. I have to ask myself how I feel about these helpful strangers.
Are these helpful strangers giving me the tools to be a success? Are they helping themselves by judging the mechanics of my work? Or are they wanna be school teachers with a red pen stash, secreted away in their closets? What does their comments/feedback mean to me? Am I overwhelmed, or happy for the feedback, or just angry that my baby isn’t perfect?
At the end of the day, helpful strangers or not, I know love to write. So I’ll keep submitting to contests and marking one goal as being done. I’ll give thanks for the judges who want me to be a better writer (I hope). And remember that scores and comments from judges are not the enemy with a red pen. And, I laugh along the way.
Isabella








